I'm with the DJ
Monday, November 9, 2020
The Weight of the Wait
Sunday, October 25, 2020
Why the Political is Feeling So Personal in Election 2020
It's hard to believe that my last blog post was written in January of 2016. It was posted on the day of President Obama's final State of the Union Address to be exact. If you have been "around" awhile, you might recall that for quite a few years I held to a tradition of insisting that my kids watch the State of the Union Address and would subsequently write a comical "Newman kids" commentary based on their reactions during the speech. I haven't been able to bring myself to require their attendance over the past four years, let alone dig deeply enough to find any sort of humor in how they may have reacted if I had required them to attend. As many of you probably know, I was a devoted member of the Republican Party my entire adult life until Donald Trump was nominated in 2016. At that time, I would have said that my political affiliations were closely tied to my worldview as an evangelical Christian. Today, I would not identify myself with either "Republicans" or "evangelicals." This isn't to say that I have abandoned my faith in Christ. Not at all. But I have parted ways with the many people of the Christian faith that have somehow made a connection between their faith in Christ and support for a man who, in my view, embodies the antithesis of who Christ was and is. The honest journey of reaching the conclusion that both "the church" and the GOP were not at all what I thought them to be was painful and grief filled. But that isn't why I write today. I write today because I want to communicate to my loved ones why a vote for Trump is so deeply hurtful and personal to me and to my family. I am not under the impression that a few words from me will change anyone's vote. But I do hope that those who genuinely care about me and my family will have a deeper understanding of why politics has become so deeply personal and why a vote for Trump feels to me like a profound betrayal, or, more accurately, a whole host of betrayals. I will try to elaborate briefly below.
Truth- If a standard of truth from the ruler of the free world means so little that you will continue supporting him after the astounding number of blatant and documented lies this man has told while in office, I am not sure that truth means much to you, and I honestly don't know how to be in an authentic relationship with someone for whom truth means so little. Supporting Trump feels to me like a betrayal of a commitment to be truthful in your life and, therefore, in our relationship.
Dignity of Human Life- The way Trump speaks about women, minorities, immigrants, individuals with disabilities, etc. and the policies he enacts are as far from affirming of human dignity as one can get. If you aren't bothered by his harmful words and harmful policies simply because they don't harm YOU or YOURS, then I am not so sure that we have enough in common for us to be in an authentic relationship. What about ME and MINE? If "pro-life" is your one and only defense of Trump and deciding factor for voting for him, then, a) I think we define "pro-life" very differently and b)I don't understand why this is the ONLY thing regarding sanctity of life that is worth your consideration and c)I think you are very easily fooled. This brings me to a problem of mutual respect in a relationship. I don't know how to truly and authentically respect someone that has such tunnel vision on one issue regarding sanctity of life that so many other dire issues of humanity are just blatantly disregarded as unworthy of consideration. Supporting Trump feels to me like a betrayal of our common humanity.
Democracy- Trump has, more than once, refused to say that he will commit to a peaceful transfer of power. He has consistently attacked the free press. He had peaceful protestors sprayed with pepper spray. He asked the FBI director to pledge loyalty to him. And it goes on and on and on. Supporting Trump, who is so blatantly and unapologetically going against the most sacred principles of our democracy, feels to me like a betrayal of our patriotic duty as Americans.
Racial Issues- And this is where it gets the most personal to me. Trump has failed at every turn to even condemn white supremacy. He will not do it. He has failed at every turn to acknowledge the systemic racism that plagues People of Color in this nation, despite the overwhelming mountain of evidence of its existence. If you don't see it either, you haven't honestly tried to look for it. Supporting Trump feels to me like a complete and utter lack of care about the realities that my Black husband and biracial children face every single day. Just because you haven't experienced or witnessed something does not make it any less true. While it may not be your intention, please know that your vote for Trump feels to me like a betrayal of my husband and children, the people in this world that mean the most to me. I honestly don't know how to be in an authentic relationship with someone who will choose to vote for a racist president rather than standing for my family. I realize this sounds like an overly dramatic claim. But it is the reality of how I have felt for quite a long time, and it is based on a plethora of words and actions by this president.
Regardless of the outcome of this election, I am truly dreading the reality of how it will continue to impact some of my relationships for a long time. Maybe change them permanently. There was a time when a difference in political views was, for me, mostly a philosophical difference on economic, domestic, or foreign policy. In 2016 that came to an end, and in 2020 the reality of the personal nature of this election is more evident than it ever has been. I know I'm not alone in feeling this way. I have seen people on social media asking Trump supporters to unfriend them. I have talked with people who have, after serious consideration and considerable pain, cut family ties. I have witnessed people making decisions to stay home on holidays rather than gather with family members whose values have been revealed to be so painfully different from their own. There are those that would judge a person who allows politics to come between close relationships, but, in my view, it's not "the politics" that hurts the relationship. It is the values and ethics that the political decisions reveal that damage relationships. For me, pulling back from these relationships is not a punishment for how one chooses to vote. Pulling back is the result of perceiving that perhaps a person isn't who I thought they were, and maybe I'm not who they thought I was either. It's struggling to figure out what common ground can be left for moving forward regardless of how much goodness there was in the relationship in the past. It's struggling to repair a foundation of trust and respect that seems irreparably damaged by political alliances that are actually alliances to starkly differing worldviews.
Hopefully, those who take the time to read this post will be clear on my goal, which is simply to communicate why a vote for Donald Trump in this election feels like such a profound betrayal to me. I recently ended a text to a fairly close family member in Pennsylvania with, "P.S. Please tell me you aren't voting for Trump." My relative ultimately replied, "I don't like being told how to vote." It caused a conflict I did not expect, and in retrospect, I wish I had written this blog sooner in an honest effort to communicate how I am experiencing my loved ones' support of Trump rather than communicating that I'm trying to "tell" someone how to vote. Thanks for taking the time to read my thoughts and hear my voice, even if doing so has been difficult.